09. Week 1 - Teaching 7

2025.07.29

You will have to depart leaving everything behind, so do not be attached to anything.

VGKG did not give commentary to this advice. From chapter on the Path of a Person of Middling Scope in Modern Buddhism:

๐Ÿ“–

When our consciousness departs from our body at death, all the potentialities we have accumulated in our mind by performing virtuous and non-virtuous actions will go with it. Other than these we cannot take anything out of this world. All other things deceive us. Death ends all our activities โ€“ our conversation, our eating, our meeting with friends, our sleep. Everything draws to a close on the day of our death and we must leave all things behind, even the rings on our fingers. In Tibet beggars carry a stick to defend themselves against dogs. To understand the complete deprivation of death we should remember that at the time of death beggars have to leave even this old stick, the most meagre of human possessions. All over the world we can see that names carved on stone are the only possessions of the dead.

We only take our very subtle mind and our karmic potentialities of our virtuous and non-virtuous actions. If we want to take a fortunate rebirth in our next life so we can continue with our spiritual practices, we definitely need to be able to keep a peaceful mind at the time of death to stimulate a virtuous seed to ripen at the time of death. Therefore we need refuge in our mind. Not attachment to the things of this life.

Generate compassion for lowly beings, and especially avoid despising or humiliating them.

Remember for Kadampas our main practice is compassion and wisdom. What is compassion? It is a virtuous mind that wishes others to be free from suffering. According to Sutra teachings, our compassion is our Buddha nature or seed. Because every living being has this seed of compassion, eventually all living beings will become Buddhas. For us as fortunate modern Kadampas, we have the opportunity in this life to develop our compassion and awaken our Buddha nature. How do we do that? Through sincerely relying on our SG and putting his Lamrim instructions into practice, both in the meditation session and outside of meditation. We will definitely extend and deepen our compassion until finally it transforms into Universal Compassion, which is the sincere heartfelt wish to permanently liberate all living beings from suffering. Then eventually it will transform into the compassion of a Buddha which has the actual power to liberate all living beings. When we become a Buddha we become an object of refuge and a source of happiness for all living beings.

Compassion is the root of the 3 Jewels - Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. It is the root of Buddha because all Buddhas are born of compassion. It is the root of Dharma because Buddhas teach Dharma out of compassion. It is the root of Sangha because it is by listening to and practising Dharma teachings given out of compassion that we will become superior beings and become and actual Sangha Jewel.

Compassion is the very essence of our Kadampa spiritual life.

1994:

We should think about and check these words carefully. Also we may already have some previous understanding about this through reading Lamrim books. There are some important things that we should know from the explanation on how to train in compassion for living beings that is mentioned in Lamrim teachings. Here is says, “generate compassion for lowly beings”. From this teaching we can understand that there are 3 different types of training in compassion for all living beings. It implies that there is training in compassion for all living beings, for practitioners who have higher intelligence or faculties; training in compassion for all living beings for practitioners who have middling faculties or capacity; and training in compassion for all living beings for practitioners who have lesser faculties or intelligence. The reason why 3 different explanations are presented is because practitioners have different capacities. Some practitioners are of initial scope. Others are of middling scope. And others are of higher scope. Therefore there are different instructions given by previous lamas. The first instruction on how to train in compassion for all living beings is for practitioners of the highest level or capacity and is mentioned in Guide to the Middle Way by Chandrakirti.

Geshe-la’s commentary to Guide to the Middle Way is Ocean of Nectar.

The 2nd instruction is mentioned in Lamrim instructions by Atisha. And the 3rd explanation of training in compassion for all living beings for practitioners who are less able is given in this advice from Atisha’s heart. So we can choose any of these 3 possibilities according to our own ability.

Guide to the Middle Way explains how to train in compassion for all living beings in the following way:

The practitioner first tries to understand that their I or self is impermanent. Or we can say that our I is absent of a permanent I. That there is an emptiness of a permanent I. In reality this is the ultimate view of the Vaibashika. Buddha taught this for his Vaibashika followers. It is a very powerful view and it is very suitable for us. It is very suitable for the beginner. Through this the practitioner tries to understand clearly how their I or self is impermanent, changing moment by moment. The I itself is momentary, not remaining in the 2nd moment.

This is Buddha’s teaching on subtle impermanence. Geshe-la says that when we realise subtle impermanence it’s almost the same as realising emptiness.

Through understanding and contemplating this view the Lamrim practitioner thinks: “I may die right now.” When this thought develops and is maintained day and night he immediately realises that if he dies right now, in the next moment he will have to take cyclic rebirth again. Then he will think, “I will therefore have to experience new sufferings, problems, and fears”. The practitioner will find this very difficult to accept, and will feel very uncomfortable.

We should feel uncomfortable about remaining in an endless cycle of suffering, death, and uncontrolled rebirth. That will move us to attain liberation.

He will think, “I am tired of samsara. Since beginningless time I have experienced this, and now I must experience this. I have obtained a meaningful form and a precious human life, but if I die today without any attainments of any spiritual realisations, with no actual refuge and protection, then I will lose a great thing, and then again I will have to experience cyclic rebirth. Then I will continue to experience the sufferings of ageing, sickness, death, and again rebirth. Between these 2 I will have to experience so many horrible things. I have no idea where I will be reborn. Maybe it will be in the lower realms. I have not finished my practice of purification, I have no confidence I have engaged in moral discipline purely, because for most of my life I have been distracted in worldly things. How can I bear taking cyclic rebirth again? Thinking like this, the practitioner will develop fear of cyclic rebirth and maintain this fear continuously. The fear of taking cyclic rebirth, or uncontrolled rebirth, directly produces renunciation. This is the wish to become completely free from cyclic rebirth NOW, before death. This fear will urge or push the practitioner to accomplish refuge now, to accomplish the spiritual path now, to accomplish the permanent cessation of self-grasping now. Renunciation will therefore naturally develop.

In OIOM, Geshe-la says usually there is no reason to develop fear. But the fear we are developing now - this fear is extremely meaningful. This fear is an essential cause of the pure practice of refuge. This fear and faith in the 3 Jewels are the actual causes of refuge. This is wisdom fear.

Then because the practitioner is of higher faculty, his idea or way of thinking will move or shift to other beings. His mind will then focus on all mother sentient beings and he will realise that all these sentient beings, due to their ignorance, are strongly grasping onto a permanent I or self. This is due to their lacking the knowledge that the self or I is impermanent. They are grasping continually at the I and believing that it will last forever, that it is permanent. Because of this strong mind of grasping at a permanent I, or a strong belief that the self or I will remain forever, they will then think, “I need such and such things.” To fulfil these wishes they will engage in contaminated actions, which are the main causes of throwing themselves into cyclic rebirths. Through these actions they will have to experience cyclic rebirth again and again. If they are born in an animal realm they will have to experience the sufferings of an animal. If they are born as a human they will experience the sufferings of human beings, and so forth. Through contemplating this the practitioner develops a strong thought, “How wonderful it would be if all these beings were free from cyclic rebirth. How wonderful if they achieved a cessation of uncontrolled rebirth.” He or she will concentrate on all sentient beings, and thinking of their suffering nature, strongly develop this wish. This wish for all living beings to be free from cyclic rebirth is compassion for all living beings. When this compassion develops within their mind, they try to maintain it continually both day and night. This compassion is the main or direct cause of Mahayana refuge. This is explained in Guide to the Middle Way.

Something so special is happening in our mental continuum when we generate this wish, even for a moment. The only things stopping us know are our distractions and our forgetfulness. We have the instructions. We can pray to remember Dharma. Try to develop these kinds of thoughts more and more every day.

“How wonderful it would be if all living beings were free from cyclic rebirth.”

As you know in Lamrim teachings the way of presenting how to develop compassion is different. First the practitioner tries to understand or develop the special recognition that all sentient beings have been their mother, and then develop affectionate love for them. Then by contemplating and meditating how these living beings are experiencing suffering, they develop compassion equally for all living beings. Chandrakirti’s explanation is a little bit technical, but it is powerful. The 2nd instruction according to Lamrim is more simple but also powerful.

The 3rd instruction explained here, the instruction for practitioners of lower faculties, is very simple. Atisha says, “Generate compassion for lowly beings.” How do we develop compassion equally for all living beings through this instruction? First we should train in compassion for all lowly beings. This means beings who are experiencing very poor conditions. Contemplate how they are poor, how they experience difficult things. Then gradually our capacity will improve, and we can shift our compassion towards higher beings - people who are experiencing good conditions, samsaric higher beings such as gods and humans, who are experiencing good conditions. Although right now they are experiencing good conditions, in reality they are experiencing many different kinds of suffering, from attachment, anger, and ignorance. Finally the practitioner will develop compassion for all living beings without exception. Here, Atisha is leading us gradually step by step to attain this compassion. First, we generate compassion for a small group who are experiencing poor conditions. Then gradually we extend our compassion until it becomes larger and larger. Finally all sentient beings become the object of our compassion. And the practitioner develops compassion for all living beings without exception. This is the most simple process for the beginner. It is a very good method.

Reading from the chapter on Compassion in HTTYL:

๐Ÿ“–

To begin with, we can think about those who are suffering intense manifest pain right now. There are so many people experiencing terrible mental and physical suffering from illnesses such as cancer, AIDS and Parkinsonโ€™s disease. How many people have lost a beloved child or friend through the scourge of cancer, watching him become weaker and weaker, knowing that it is difficult to cure? Every day, thousands of people experience the agony of dying from illnesses or in accidents. Without choice they are separated forever from everyone they love, and those they leave behind often experience inconsolable grief and loneliness. Imagine an old woman losing her husband and lifelong partner, sadly returning home after the funeral to an empty house to live out the rest of her days alone.

Throughout the world we can see how millions of people are suffering through the horrors of war and ethnic cleansing, from bombing, landmines and massacres. Suppose it was your child who went out to play in the fields and lost a limb, or even his very life, by stepping on a landmine?

Others’ wish to be free from suffering is no different from our wish for ourselves to be free from suffering. There is no difference. We can try to empathise with them, and feel their pain as keenly as it was our own. “What if that were me? What if that were my own family?” Then our mind moves, so we can start to develop a wish for them to be free from their suffering as if we were wishing it for ourself.

๐Ÿ“–

Hundreds of thousands of refugees throughout the world live in squalid camps, hoping someday to return to their ruined homes, many of them waiting to be reunited with their loved ones, every day not knowing if they are alive or dead.

Every year natural disasters such as floods, earthquakes and hurricanes devastate whole communities and leave people homeless and hungry. A few short seconds of an earthquake can kill thousands of people, destroy their homes and bury everything under tons of rubble. Think how we would feel if this were to happen to us. Famine and drought are endemic in many countries throughout the world. So many people live on a subsistence diet, barely scraping together one meagre meal a day, while others who are less fortunate succumb and die of starvation. Imagine the torment of watching your loved ones slowly waste away, knowing that there is nothing you can do. Whenever we read, listen to or watch the news, we see living beings who are in terrible pain, and we all personally know people who are experiencing immense mental or physical suffering.

We can contemplate like this, and generate compassion for people experiencing poor conditions and horrible sufferings right now, and then gradually extend that compassion to finally include all living beings. Because while we remain in samsara it’s just a matter of time before we experience these horrible sufferings.

“I must liberate all living beings permanently from the cycle of suffering.”

We must practise this not only to lowly beings. First we learn the practice for lowly beings, or beings experiencing poor conditions, and then gradually we should expand this to include even the higher beings in samsara. Finally we should avoid despising or humiliating each and every living being. If we check this, many questions arise. Whether we are humiliating depends in reality upon our motivation. Just pointing out another’s faults and saying, “you are wrong, you should not do this,” is not necessarily an attempt to humiliate them.

At this point we have received the commentary to the first half of Atisha’s Advice. And in the 2nd week we have the opportunity to receive the commentary to the second half, with Gen-la Dekyong. How wonderful. Starting tomorrow we have the great opportunity to engage in meditation retreat. Some of VGKG’s advice on engaging in retreat on Atisha’s Advice. It’s very simple - we should use the Preliminary Prayers for Meditation. And then we should engage in the meditation after receiving blessings. We should first contemplate Atisha’s Advice, and then contemplate VGKG’s commentary to that advice. Then through that contemplation we come to a conclusion which is the final object of meditation. We then hold it with mindfulness and remain on it in single-pointed concentration for as long as possible. And become more and more familiar with it.